When did Jesus cleanse the temple? Is this really a contradiction?
No Flash Support? Use this Audio Player!
Download the MP3
Dave: When did Jesus cleanse the Temple? In John 2 it seems like it was earlier in his ministry, but in Mark 11 it suggests that it was later on.
Jeff: This reflects a misunderstanding of how the Gospels are written.
Dave: In our CRACKED acronym, the “D” stands for Dialect – what type of genre, vernacular or dialect is being used?
Jeff: For instance, if I say, “We won the football game by a million points!” I’m using hyperbole to make my point.
Dave: So, back to Jesus cleansing the Temple – when did it happen? Remember the dialect…
Jeff: The Gospels are not all written chronologically.
Dave: For us, we expect a story or historical account to start at the beginning, and proceed sequentially. But, that’s not how writers have always inked their pages.
Jeff: John ordered his Gospel by thematic elements. Mark may have ordered his chronologically, although some suggest his was thematic as well.
Dave: So overall the books are thematic. Yet, there is one little clue about when it happened in both Gospels – they both say it was around the Jewish Passover.
Jeff: The same answer from both.