Posted by Dave


When did Jesus cleanse the temple? Is this really a contradiction?

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

No Flash Support? Use this Audio Player!

Download the MP3


Dave: When did Jesus cleanse the Temple? In John 2 it seems like it was earlier in his ministry, but in Mark 11 it suggests that it was later on.

Jeff: This reflects a misunderstanding of how the Gospels are written.

Dave: In our CRACKED acronym, the “D” stands for Dialect – what type of genre, vernacular or dialect is being used?

Jeff: For instance, if I say, “We won the football game by a million points!” I’m using hyperbole to make my point.

Dave: So, back to Jesus cleansing the Temple – when did it happen? Remember the dialect…

Jeff: The Gospels are not all written chronologically.

Dave: For us, we expect a story or historical account to start at the beginning, and proceed sequentially. But, that’s not how writers have always inked their pages.

Jeff: John ordered his Gospel by thematic elements. Mark may have ordered his chronologically, although some suggest his was thematic as well.

Dave: So overall the books are thematic. Yet, there is one little clue about when it happened in both Gospels – they both say it was around the Jewish Passover.

Jeff: The same answer from both.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *