Did our last Truth Shot confuse you? Don’t feel alone. It’s a typical first reaction to the Vertical Cosmological Argument. We take a quick 60 seconds to break it down.
Download the MP3
Dave: In the last Truth Shot we talked about the Vertical Cosmological argument.
Jeff: Yep, basically, everything in our Universe depends upon something else for its
existence (you need water, trees need sunlight)
Dave: So the whole universe must be dependent upon something outside itself.
Jeff: Right, and that would be God.
Dave: But can’t dependent things help each other? Like the sun gives trees what they
need… so when you combine things, they are different and not needy!
Jeff: Right – can’t our universe just pass around what we need to each other?
Jeff: No. it’d only be true if being “dependent” wasn’t our fundamental value. If you put
a triangle with another triangle..
Dave: it becomes a square, it’s different!
Jeff: Right. But it’s still a geometric shape. That’s the most fundamental piece about it.
That will never change.
Dave: Okay, so what matters when you combine things is their fundamental attributes
Jeff: Yes. And being dependent is completely fundamental to everything in our universe.
Dave: So our universe must be dependent on something outside of itself –
Jeff: – God.
Leave a Reply